“Thriller” may have been the Michael Jackson video most fans wanted to watch, but it surprisingly wasn’t the song most people wanted to play, play, play.

According to Billboard, it was a tune that Jackson did with Paul McCartney that ranks as the late singer’s best hit. “Say, Say, Say” topped a list of 50 tracks followed by “Billie Jean” and “I’ll Be There.”

The list, which was compiled to help commemorate the upcoming anniversary of Michael’s death (June 25), took a number of factors into consideration to determine a track’s performance in the Hot 100. (You can read the full explanation behind the inverse point system here.) Although “Billie Jean” spent more weeks at #1, the Jackson/McCartney collaboration lasted longer on the charts.

Here are Michael Jackson’s Top 10 Billboard hits:

1. “Say, Say, Say”
2. “Billie Jean”
3. “I’ll Be There”
4. “Beat It”
5. “Rock With You”
6. “Dance Machine”
7. “Man in the Mirror”
8. “I Want You Back”
9. “ABC”
10. “The Girl is Mine”