When you don’t have a soap opera fan base supporting you, a large asset on you or eighty years of living behind you—chances are, you’re going to be eliminated. And that was precisely the case for Ted McGinley.

Tonight on Dancing with the Stars: Season 7, the Love Boat/Married with Children/Hope & Faith/Happy Days star was asked to leave the parquet floor. His elimination came one day after comedian Jeffrey Ross was sent home with only one eye.

Although McGinley was not the competition’s lowest scorer - his his combined total of 35 bested Cloris Leachman’s 32 - no one expected the feisty octogenarian would be going anywhere quite so soon. And while he was technically tied with Susan Lucci and lazy Kim Kardashian coming into this evening, his charm was outmatched by their appeal.

So who do you think will be up on the chopping block next? How long will Cloris be able to survive on her sass alone? Is Lance Bass’ boy band background an unfair advantage? Let us know what you think!

(You can find all the Dancing with the Stars: Season 7 posts here.)