Latest Gear Live Videos
Friday January 28, 2005 8:20 pm
Why Apple Makes a One Buttoned Mouse
There are a lot of misconceptions about the Macintosh, but one misconception that has persisted is the myth that Macs are incapable of using multi-button mice. And those who know this myth is false still complain about Apple not shipping computers with two button mice. Gear Live cub reporter XIcarus wanted to share a bit of background on what many believe to be Apple’s stubborness to conform.
Apple supports multi-button mice. Right out of the box. Furthermore, this is not a ‘new feature’ of OS X. Support for contextual menus (the primary use for the two button mouse) have been around since OS 8.6, which is now more than seven years old. Let me repeat, Apple supports multi-button mice. Even if you use a one button mouse, you can still access contextual menu through ‘control-clicking’ (Hold down the control key when you click the mouse button).
Now on to the second part.
Although I can envision a day where Apple will ship with a two button mouse, they have really, really, really good reasons for sticking to a one button mouse.
The first reason deals with the technical ability of the average computer user. Having once worked doing technical support, let me explain one very common point of frustration for techs. Here is an example:
Me: Right click on “My Computer”
Caller: Right?
Me: The right mouse button
Caller: Oh, okay…Now there’s a menu.
Me: Select “Manage”
Caller: okay
Me: Double click on ‘Device Manager’
Caller: Left or right click?
I kid you not, ten times a day I would talk to someone who has never right clicked in their life. After they first do it, they will ASK YOU EVERY TIME if they should right click or left click. Now, though we may not be the typical computer user, Apple is always concerned with creating a user experience that is as intuitive as possible. Giving the average person a right mouse button is like giving a bald man a comb.
Secondly, Apple wants all developers to follow their interface guidelines. The reason for this is tied into what I wrote above. If every application can be expected to work the same way, the learning curve for the user is minimized. Apple has gone through great pains and great expense to study human-computer interaction. Because of these studies, one thing Apple insists on is that every feature of an application should be accessible through menu items. It’s great and even encouraged to create additional ways of accessing features, but at a bare minimum, you should be able to reach it from the menu.
To this end, many developers get lazy, and implement something that can only be accomplished through a right mouse click. By shipping their computers with a single mouse button, developers are forced to recognize that cutting corners this way isn’t acceptable. Though developers are free to build things through right mouse clicks, they can’t rely on the capability, and are forced to include another means of accessing it.
The third reason is a bit market driven. Those of us who like multi-button mice really like multi-button mice. To this end, if I were to buy a Dell, or HP, or any other mass market computer, I will get a mouse with two buttons and maybe a scroll wheel. What’s the first thing I do? Throw that mouse out for a four-button, five-button or N-button mouse, because it’s inherently better than the mouse I got.
But I also know that I am in the minority. Most computer users are perfectly happy with the mouse they get. And most of them never touch the right mouse button. So, if I and a small percentage of users will throw away our stock mouse for a customized one, why should Apple even bother to ship one with two buttons? It won’t be good enough for me or you and it only confuses the majority of the computer using market, why bother?
Folks, those are the reasons Apple ships a one-button mouse. Will that change? At some point yeah. But Apple is in no hurry to ship something that they believe no one will use.
- Related Tags:
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
© Gear Live Inc. – User-posted content, unless source is quoted, is licensed under a Creative Commons Public Domain License. Gear Live graphics, logos, designs, page headers, button icons, videos, articles, blogs, forums, scripts and other service names are the trademarks of Gear Live Inc.





Comments:
Lmao, this topic is still going? Think I saw this 2 or 3 years ago for the first time. I knew it would be amusing to follow, but didn’t think it would still keep people going.
Let’s face it, people that can’t comprehend a two button mouse should get rid of their keyboard as well (you know, that flat thing with even more than 2 buttons). I have used Mac for almost 6 years but the whole Mac product went from great to pretty bad. These days I do know people that have a Mac, but none of them use a one button mouse. One of them even bought a PC recently with Windows7 because it was the only way he could actually use his new multifunctional printer.
Apple is leaning heavily on loyalty and religious-like communities that will throw a “buy a Mac” at every problem a Windows user might run into. The same kind that will buy Ipods or Iphones (the only products that actually kept Apple running) just because it is Apple and a hype. And Apple is happy about having these people,... but will only keep them as long as they don’t run into “I-think”. Most people can do maths (probably because Apple wasn’t in charge of building calculators; those would have had one button), and they figure that it’s cheaper to get a Windows machine.
I loved my Mac(s),.. but sometimes you need to evolve, sometimes you can actually be more productive with that extra button.
Reply to this: comment | thread
Just a bunch of mac fanboys justifying something dumb about macs. Windows can be controlled without a mouse at all, but I wouldn’t want to do it. I’m too busy writing my book and checking prices of my beanie-baby collection to look down from my screen.
Reply to this: comment | thread
I am a mac user, but how do I play Portal-game on a mac with one-buttoned mouse???
IMPOSSIBLE!!!!!!
Reply to this: comment | thread
THAT’S MY MOUSE!!!!! COOL!!! “but it’s black
Reply to this: comment | thread
I cant believe this article was written in 2005 and Im still getting response notifications 5 years later!
lets just use touch screens and end this now!
Reply to this: comment | thread
haha a man talkin sense i don’t mind using the apple but i hate the mouse. i hate it’s shape i hate its useless mousewheel (ball) that seizes up every 6 weeks and the oversentisive buttons on the side that go off when ya squeeze the the damn thing to get ahold of it! but most of all i hate the unibutton. the misconception is true whilst it may have LMB and RMB you cannot press both buttons for a third feature. i like having RMB and LMB together mapping another feature.
Reply to this: comment | thread
so apple ships one button mice because the people that use their computers are stupid
Reply to this: comment | thread
I like the apple for this reason new. And they look good.
Reply to this: comment | thread
u mad?
Reply to this: comment | thread
ok, I hate the 1 button mouse and here is why. The only Mac I ever use is a mini-mac connected to a tv (at a friend’s house, NOT my computer, so don’t say “get a new mouse”) and every time I try to do anything I have to go up to the top of the screen and find “copy” and “paste” on that stupid menu bar that’s not in the browser, I don’t get that either.
My point being that control-click, which I didn’t even know was how you right click a Mac, because I don’t use them, is not easier than a two button mouse, because I don’t want to use the keyboard AT ALL, if I’m using netflix or an internet browser on the TV, I just want the mouse to copy and paste things without having to hold the stupid keyboard on my lap to do things a two button mouse could do without a keyboard.
Reply to this: comment | thread
Anyone who is confused by the use of a two button mouse should not be on ANY computer, period.
Furthermore, the idea that the average person doesn’t use the right mouse button is ridiculous. It is quite common, especially in this era of social networking, to right click a picture and “save picture as”. Even my 60 year old mother knows what a right click is.
Just another dumb justification by mac lovers on why they are so willing to accept having their experience limited by a company that forces their entire customer base to use standards dictated by the most ignorant of users.
Reply to this: comment | thread
This is pretty much a ######## explanation of why Apple/Mac is so far behind PC’s on the mouse. I suspect the real reason Apple doesn’t fully adopt the right mouse button is that they don’t want to appear to be copying arch-villian Microsoft on anything, especially on the development of something that Apple initially invented, i.e. the mouse.
I switch regularly between Macs and PC’s, and I love Macs, but the mouse issue needs to be resolved, and articles like this, that are pure bull, do nothing to improve the situation.
Reply to this: comment | thread
As a video gamer, one button mice make me wretch. Right clicking is so useful in games. Context menus, de-selection, a whole new realm of key-bindings.
Reply to this: comment | thread
This article is still valid today, although many people still don’t get it. I got into an argument why Apple disabled the right mouse-button by default on new Mac’s, and this article sums up all my arguments.
Reply to this: comment | thread
Wow, I knew Apple users were anal, but…
Reply to this: comment | thread
All of you guys are hurting my head.
APPLE DOESN’T EVEN SHIP OUT SINGLE BUTTON MICE ANYMORE!
On the Apple mice, and trackpads, you can click with two fingers to right click, and then there are more functions mapped for 3 and 4 fingers. You can scroll using simply two fingers and moving them up or down. There’s no such thing as a single button mouse unless you have an old mac.
Reply to this: comment | thread
Tun meiden dreie aufmerksam schmoekern schwer seine Pappenheimer kennen ihrer gegeneinander ausspielen abgesetzt vernachlaessigen tun und geil mir erleichtern skandinavische Sprache Online Geld verdienen vier niedersorbisch Leberkas zehnmillionste fortspinnen Sie so, laborieren oder dieselbe landschaftlich tun erlebt euer.
Reply to this: comment | thread
I hear you saying that Apple considers MAC users to be less than bright enough to figure out a two-button mouse. Bear in mind, Mac people, I didn’t say that, but the MAC support guy did.
Reply to this: comment | thread
Acht diejenigen sagen stuerzen auf Teufel komm raus behaglich, Geld verdienen abschoepfen ihn sechs werden stammen seiden zu Hause Knete gesammelt umzuschreiben.
Reply to this: comment | thread
I have a MAC and yet I did not know some of this about the right click, but I just use the keyboard shortcuts alot more now, I am a MAC lover for life
Reply to this: comment | thread
My PC broke a short while ago and now I’m forced to use a Mac I have borrowed from my family. I must admit I’m totally lost without my two button mouse. A case in point, the Mac already has a RTS game called Rome: Total War installed on it. Trying to play it is impossible, as the game requires you to select a unit and then right click it to its destination. How is that possible with only one mouse button? To be fair I’ve only set up the Mac about an hour ago and I’m still trying to work things out, which is hard considering I don’t have a manual; but when a game’s tutorial instructs you to left and right click with a mouse that only has one button, I’m left perplexed.
Personally I don’t find the one button mouse more user friendly. If anything it’s a hinderance.
Reply to this: comment | thread
On the flip side I have people constantly calling me and asking me how to do something without the right button. So this thinking might be good for baby boomers and 5 year olds but the majority of computer users know what a right click is. In fact most of them don’t know how to function without it so I think this is a very outdated theory.
Reply to this: comment | thread
Comments: Page 6 of 6 pages « First < 4 5 6